Wellness for Judges

Content Creator: Thomas A. Zonay, Chief Superior Court Judge State of Vermont


Wellness for Judges

1. Stress Is Inherent in Judicial Work

  • Judging involves constant intellectual and emotional demands.

  • Stress is defined as any factor causing physical or mental tension, and it can contribute to illness.

2. Types of Stress

  • Acute stress: short-term, resolves quickly.

  • Chronic stress: persistent, harmful to mental and physical health.

3. Major Causes of Judicial Stress

Professional & Role-Related

  • Isolation (both personal and professional).

  • Unrealistic expectations of being “all‑wise” or always composed.

  • Ethical constraints preventing judges from responding to criticism.

  • Loss of control over schedules, deadlines, emergencies, and 24/7 responsibilities.

  • Heavy workload, expanding dockets, and insufficient time for writing and file review.

  • Exposure to traumatic content (violence, abuse, neglect) leading to secondary trauma.

  • Difficult litigants, self‑represented parties, and unprepared attorneys.

  • Pressure of high‑profile cases, media scrutiny, and public criticism.

  • Safety and security concerns, including threats and loss of privacy.

Personal

  • Family responsibilities, financial strain, health issues.

Environmental & Systemic

  • Court culture and management.

  • Physical work environment.

  • Commuting.

  • Conflicting roles and limited ability to do what feels morally “right”.

  • Fear of making the wrong decision.

  • Need to maintain emotional restraint (“game face”).

4. How Stress Manifests

Physical

  • Fatigue, muscle tension, headaches, sleep issues, heart problems, GI issues, appetite changes.

Psychological

  • Depression, anxiety, irritability, pessimism, overwhelm, concentration problems, decision fatigue.

  • Vicarious trauma resembling PTSD symptoms.

Behavioral

  • Mood swings, anger, frustration, lashing out.

  • Increased alcohol or drug use.

  • Decline in work performance.

5. Addressing Judicial Stress

Foundational Steps

  • Acknowledge that judicial stress is real and universal.

  • Commit to taking time to address it.

  • Decide on changes and follow through.

Physical Well‑Being

  • Regular medical care.

  • Healthy eating.

  • Exercise.

  • Monitoring alcohol use.

  • Adequate sleep.

Support Systems

  • Colleagues (“Is it me, or…” conversations).

  • Family and friends.

  • Professional help (therapy, counseling, medical care).

Time for Self & Family

  • Protecting personal time and boundaries.

Judicial Education

  • Learning, improving, and recharging through training.

Peer Connection

  • One of the most effective stress relievers is connecting with other judges for solidarity and shared experience—whether in person or electronically.

Supporting Each Other

  • Make time for colleagues.

  • Notice signs of struggle.

  • Offer assistance.

  • Remind each other that judges did not create the problems they must resolve.

6. Resources Provided

  • Judicial wellness articles and initiatives from:

    • Judge Gerald Lebovits

    • Colorado Judicial Well‑Being

    • NCJFCJ Wellness Initiative

    • NCSC Wellness Guide

    • Federal Judicial Center (Mindfulness and Judging)



© Copyright 2024 National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary 


Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software